Diversity of electeds: Elected officials should reflect the diversity of the population.
Insights & Analyses
- While the region is 62 percent people of color, people of color hold just 37 percent of top local elected offices.
- Regionwide, men are overrepresented in top elected positions, but women have gained ground, increasing their share of seats to 48 percent as of January 2023, from 44 percent in July 2019.
- Asian Americans and Latinx populations continue to be sorely underrepresented among local electeds. Latinx and Asian Americans make up half of the region’s population but are just 25 percent of top local elected officials.
- Among the nine counties, San Mateo County has the highest overrepresentation of white elected officials compared to its population as a whole.
September 21, 2023: Bay Area Elected Officials Still Don’t Reflect the Region’s DiversityBay Area Elected Officials Still Don’t Reflect the Region’s Diversity
A Closer Look at Landlord Elected Officials and Tenant Protection Legislation in the Bay Area
People of Color Continue to Make Modest Gains in Bay Area’s Halls of Power (September 15, 2023)
August 25, 2021: More People of Color Are Running For and Winning Local Offices, But Bay Area Electeds Still Do Not Represent the Region’s Diversity
May 13, 2020: Bay Area Asian Population Strong in Numbers, Vastly Underrepresented in Politics
May 13, 2020: Bay Area's Latinx Population Remains Highly Underrepresented in Local Politics
February 27, 2020: Despite Progress Since 2018, Bay Area Diversity Not Reflected Among Top Local Electeds
Drivers of Inequity
The underrepresentation of people of color in elected offices — even in jurisdictions with large communities of color — is an outcome of the deep legacy of racial exclusion in electoral politics throughout American history. Since the end of the Civil War, racist public institutions and civilians have used a variety of mechanisms — poll taxes, residency requirements, literacy tests, intimidation, and physical violence — to deny Black people their right to vote. In many jurisdictions, legislatures have used (and continue to use) gerrymandering to split voters of color across electoral districts and thus dilute their political power, or run at-large elections that can overlook the concerns of smaller voting blocs. Long hours, low pay for electoral work, and the high costs of running a campaign disproportionately disadvantage people of color and low-income candidates who have limited personal wealth. The increasing flood of private-sector money into local campaigns adds to the financial challenge for candidates attentive to working-class concerns. With so few electeds from working-class communities of color, there is also limited existing organizational infrastructure to recruit, train, organize, and mentor promising young people in campaigns and electoral politics.
Strategies
Build community power: Strategies to increase political representation and power
-
Establish public campaign financing that addresses funding barriers for people of color seeking office.
-
Pass campaign financing reforms that limit "pay-to-play" politics and the influence of big money in local elections.
-
Consider switching from at-large to district-based elections, which increases the likelihood that elected officials will represent and address the interests of smaller voting blocs.
-
Expand leadership development programs that prepare people from low-income communities and communities of color to run for and win elected office, manage electoral campaigns, and effectively engage in public policy as staffers and advocates.
-
Strengthen democracy by increasing electoral participation among marginalized groups, expanding voting rights, and preventing the future rollback of voting rights.
-
Support community organizations that mobilize residents in harder-to-reach communities around civic engagement and democratic participation, especially young people.
- Foster racial inclusion in governance and multiracial alliances, coalitions, and movements to advance policy change.
Strategy in Action
Urban Habitat’s Boards and Commissions Leadership Institute (BCLI) trains the next generation of leaders. Since 2010, BCLI has been training leaders from underrepresented Bay Area communities to serve on decision-making bodies. The program empowers residents to lead on the issues that most directly impact their neighborhoods, including transportation, housing, and jobs. BCLI alumni have won more than 40 seats on city councils, priority boards, and commissions, including planning commissions, housing authorities, and rent boards. The program has been replicated in other metros, including the Twin Cities and Sacramento. Learn more.
In Their Own Words...
“ I didn't want to be an elected official, but I was motivated to run for office because I just didn't see anybody in the race who was going to be willing to have values radical enough to do what residents actually needed to be done.”
Antioch City Councilmember Tamisha Torres-Walker had no political ambition — an admission of her own. However, she ran for office because she felt that none of the other candidates reflected the values and lived experiences of the city’s communities of color. People of color account for 73 percent of Antioch’s total population, but only 45 percent of elected officials representing the city, which includes Contra Costa County electeds, are people of color. When Councilmember Torres-Walker won her first term in 2020, she became the first Black Latina to join the five-member city council. She stepped into office clear on her priorities: to uplift and support communities of color. During her tenure, she has helped pass progressive policies like rent stabilization, guided the creation of a mobile mental health crisis team, and secured funding for transitional housing and violence prevention. Learn more.
Photo: Felix Uribe
Resources
- Organizations: Bay Rising; California Calls; Center for Inclusive Democracy
- Reports: Everyone Wins When Our Elected Officials Reflect the Diversity of the Region; Reducing the Voter Turnout Gap in San Francisco; Unleashing Latino Voting Power: Strategies to Boost Voter Participation Among Latino Youth; Designing Public Financing Systems to Advance Equity and Independent Political Power; Black Mayors are Leading the Nation’s Biggest Cities for the First Time
- Data: How Much Does the Legislature Look Like California?